Place paprika chicken thighs onto raw wedged potatoes, paired with 2 ingredients, into slow cooker for a rustic supper that’s my default when I don't know what to make

This slow cooker 4-ingredient Amish-style paprika chicken and potatoes is the rustic supper I turn to when I honestly don’t know what to make. It’s inspired by the kind of simple, no-fuss cooking you still find in small Midwestern and Amish communities—hearty, humble, and built from pantry basics. You just wedge some raw potatoes, tuck them into the slow cooker, and lay paprika-rubbed chicken thighs right on top with two more simple ingredients. By dinnertime, you’ve got tender potatoes soaked in chicken juices and cozy, flavorful chicken that tastes like you fussed, even though you didn’t.

I like to scoop the potatoes into shallow bowls, nestle a chicken thigh or two on top, and spoon some of the paprika-tinted juices over everything. A simple green side—like steamed green beans, a tossed salad, or buttered peas—keeps the meal feeling fresh. Warm dinner rolls or a slice of crusty bread are perfect for soaking up the juices. If you want to stretch the meal, serve it with a side of applesauce or coleslaw, which fits that old-fashioned farmhouse feel.

Servings: 4

2 lb russet or Yukon Gold potatoes, scrubbed and cut into thick wedges

Prep the potatoes: Scrub the potatoes well and cut them into thick wedges (about 6–8 wedges per potato). There’s no need to peel unless your family prefers them that way.

Layer the potatoes: Place the raw potato wedges into the bottom of your slow cooker, spreading them into an even layer. If using the onion, scatter the sliced onion over the potatoes. Pour the chicken broth or water evenly over the potatoes to help them steam and soften.

Season the chicken: In a small bowl, stir together the paprika, salt, and black pepper. Pat the chicken thighs dry with paper towels, then rub them all over with the olive oil or melted butter.

Coat with paprika mixture: Sprinkle the paprika mixture evenly over all sides of the chicken thighs, pressing gently so it sticks. You want the chicken well coated so it turns a deep, brick-red color.

Place chicken onto potatoes: Set the seasoned paprika chicken thighs directly on top of the raw potato wedges in a single layer, skin side up if using skin-on thighs. This lets the juices from the chicken drip down and flavor the potatoes as everything cooks.

Slow cook: Cover the slow cooker with the lid. Cook on LOW for 6–7 hours, or on HIGH for 3–4 hours, until the chicken is very tender and the potatoes are soft when pierced with a fork.

Optional finish for crispy skin: If you’d like a bit of crisp on the chicken skin, carefully transfer the cooked thighs to a foil-lined baking sheet and broil on the top oven rack for 3–5 minutes, watching closely so they don’t burn.

Taste and serve: Gently stir the potatoes in the bottom of the slow cooker to coat them with the paprika-tinted juices. Taste and add a pinch more salt if needed. Serve the potatoes in bowls or on plates, topped with a chicken thigh and a spoonful of the cooking juices.

For picky eaters, you can go lighter on the paprika and sprinkle a little extra salt on one or two plain thighs before cooking; those will taste milder. If your family doesn’t like onion pieces, leave the onion out entirely or use 1/2 teaspoon onion powder mixed into the paprika instead. To make it a bit creamier, stir 2–3 tablespoons of sour cream into the potatoes right before serving, which gives a tangy, almost stroganoff-style feel. You can also swap in smoked paprika for part of the sweet paprika if your crew enjoys a gentle smoky flavor. For extra veggies, tuck a handful of baby carrots or thick carrot coins in with the potatoes. If you only have boneless, skinless chicken thighs, they’ll still work—just reduce the cooking time slightly (about 5–6 hours on LOW, 2 1/2–3 1/2 hours on HIGH) and know you won’t get crispy skin, but the meat will be very tender. Leftovers reheat well; I like to mash the leftover potatoes a bit and shred the chicken over the top for an easy next-day lunch.