Set this before church and came home to chicken so tender it was falling off the bone. The sauce had everyone asking what my secret was.

This 4-ingredient slow cooker Sunday butter chicken using a whole chicken is the kind of meal you set before church and come home to, with the house smelling like you’ve been tending the stove all morning. It’s my simple, Midwestern answer to those busy Sundays when you still want a sit-down dinner that feels special. The chicken turns so tender it falls right off the bone, and the buttery, tomato-cream sauce tastes far fussier than it is. This is the sort of recipe my mother would have loved: pantry ingredients, one pot, and a comforting gravy that has everyone at the table asking what your secret is.

Serve this tender butter chicken carved on a rustic wooden board, then spoon the rich sauce from the slow cooker over the pieces. It’s wonderful with mashed potatoes or buttered egg noodles to catch every bit of the gravy. Steamed green beans, sweet corn, or a simple side salad round out the plate nicely. A loaf of warm crusty bread or dinner rolls is perfect for sopping up the extra sauce, and if you like, finish the meal with something simple and homey like apple crisp or vanilla ice cream.

Servings: 6-8

1 whole chicken (4–5 pounds), giblets removed and patted dry

Prepare the slow cooker and chicken: Set a large slow cooker (5–7 quarts) on the counter. Remove the giblets from the whole chicken if they are still inside, and pat the chicken very dry with paper towels, inside and out. This helps the skin cook up more attractively and keeps excess water out of the sauce.

Season the chicken (optional but recommended): Sprinkle the chicken all over with the kosher salt and black pepper, including a light sprinkle in the cavity. You don’t need anything fancy here; the butter and sauce will do most of the work, but a little seasoning wakes everything up.

Layer butter in the slow cooker: Scatter half of the butter chunks in the bottom of the slow cooker, roughly in the shape of where the chicken will sit. This creates a rich base that mingles with the juices as the bird cooks.

Nestle in the whole chicken: Place the whole chicken breast-side up directly on top of the butter in the slow cooker. Tuck the wing tips under if you like, and make sure the lid will close snugly.

Add sauce and remaining butter: Pour the entire jar of tomato pasta sauce evenly over the chicken, letting it run down over the sides into the bottom. Dot the top of the chicken and the sauce around it with the remaining butter chunks.

Slow cook until falling off the bone: Cover with the lid and cook on LOW for 6–8 hours, or until the chicken is very tender and the leg wiggles easily and almost falls away from the body. (Most average 4–5 pound chickens are perfect around the 7-hour mark, which makes this easy to set before church and return to later.) Avoid lifting the lid during cooking so the heat stays consistent.

Finish the buttery cream sauce: When the chicken is fully cooked and very tender, carefully ladle or pour most of the cooking liquid from the slow cooker into a large heatproof bowl or measuring cup. Let it sit a minute so the fat rises to the top, then skim off some of the excess fat if you prefer a lighter sauce. Return the skimmed liquid to the slow cooker. Stir in the heavy cream, mixing it gently into the tomato-butter juices until the sauce is smooth and a lovely rosy color. Taste and adjust salt and pepper if needed.

Crisp the skin for a roasted look (optional but matches the photo): To get that golden, rustic, roasted look with juices pooling on a wooden board, carefully lift the whole chicken from the slow cooker using two large spatulas or slotted spoons and transfer it to a rimmed baking sheet. (It will be very tender, so support it well.) Place under a preheated broiler on the middle rack for 4–6 minutes, watching closely, until the skin is golden and lightly crisp. Don’t walk away; it can brown quickly.

Rest and carve: Let the chicken rest on a wooden cutting board for about 10 minutes so the juices settle. Carve the chicken into pieces—legs, thighs, wings, and slices of breast—letting the juices pool naturally on the board, just like a Sunday roast.

Serve with the secret sauce: Spoon some of the warm butter-tomato-cream sauce from the slow cooker over the carved chicken, and pass extra sauce at the table. The chicken should be so tender it comes off the bone with barely a nudge, and the rich, velvety sauce is what will have everyone asking what you did differently this time.

You can easily tailor this Sunday butter chicken to your own kitchen and tastes while keeping it simple. For a slightly lighter version, use half the butter and substitute half-and-half for the heavy cream; the sauce will still be silky, just not as rich. If you’d like a little more of that classic buttery “Indian restaurant” aroma without complicating things, stir 1–2 teaspoons of mild curry powder or garam masala into the tomato sauce before pouring it over the chicken. For a hint of sweetness, add 1–2 tablespoons of honey or brown sugar to the sauce. If your family likes a little heat, a pinch of red pepper flakes or a dash of hot sauce in the sauce will do the trick without making it fiery. You can also use bone-in chicken thighs or leg quarters instead of a whole chicken; reduce the cooking time slightly (usually 4–6 hours on LOW, depending on size) and watch for that same fall-off-the-bone tenderness. Leftovers keep very well—shred the remaining chicken, stir it back into the sauce, and serve over rice or noodles for an easy second meal. Food safety tips: Always start with a fully thawed chicken; never put a frozen whole chicken directly into the slow cooker, as it can sit too long at unsafe temperatures. Keep the chicken refrigerated until you’re ready to cook, and wash your hands, cutting boards, and any utensils that touch raw poultry with hot, soapy water. Make sure the chicken reaches an internal temperature of at least 165°F (74°C) in the thickest part of the thigh without touching the bone; by the time it is fall-off-the-bone tender in a slow cooker, it usually exceeds this, but it’s still wise to check with a meat thermometer. If you broil the chicken to crisp the skin, handle the hot pan carefully and allow the chicken to rest before carving so hot juices don’t splatter. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours of cooking and use within 3–4 days, or freeze for longer storage.