This Amish-style cheddar noodle bake is the kind of practical, comforting casserole that earns a regular place in a busy dinner rotation. It leans on a short list of pantry and refrigerator staples, with dry pasta baking right in the dish as the sauce forms around it, and the sharp cheddar creating the rich, homey flavor that makes the finished casserole so appealing. It’s a simple Midwestern-style supper with old-fashioned casserole sensibility: hearty, economical, and very easy to assemble.
Serve this noodle bake with a crisp green salad, steamed green beans, buttered peas, or roasted broccoli to balance its richness. For a fuller meal, add sliced ham, roast chicken, or simple pan-seared sausages on the side, and set out applesauce, dill pickles, or a spoonful of tomato relish for a classic sweet-tangy contrast.
Oven Baked 5-Ingredient Amish Cheddar Noodle Bake
Servings: 6
Ingredients
8 ounces dry tagliatelle nests
Directions
1. Preheat the oven to 375°F and lightly butter or grease a 9x13-inch glass baking dish.
2. Arrange the dry tagliatelle nests in the prepared baking dish in a mostly even layer.
3. Scatter the grated sharp cheddar evenly over the dry pasta, letting some fall between the nests.
4. In a bowl or large measuring cup, whisk together the milk and condensed cream of chicken soup until smooth, then pour the mixture evenly over the pasta and cheese. Dot the butter pieces over the top.
5. Cover the dish tightly with foil and bake for 35 minutes. Remove the foil and bake 15 to 20 minutes more, until the noodles are tender, the sauce is bubbling, and the top is lightly golden.
6. Let the casserole rest for 10 minutes before serving so the sauce can settle and the noodles can absorb the last bit of liquid.
7. Serve warm, spooning the creamy cheddar noodles onto plates.
Variations & Tips
Use a different noodle shape: If tagliatelle nests are hard to find, you can use dry egg noodles or fettuccine broken into shorter lengths. Try to keep the pasta in a fairly even layer so it cooks at the same rate and absorbs the liquid evenly.
Add a little seasoning: Even a very plain casserole benefits from a few turns of black pepper, a pinch of paprika, or a little onion powder. Amish-style bakes are often intentionally simple, but a touch of seasoning can sharpen the cheddar flavor nicely.
Make it heartier: Stir in diced cooked ham, shredded rotisserie chicken, or browned sausage before baking if you want to turn this into a more substantial one-dish supper. If adding meat, keep the pieces small so they distribute well among the noodles.
Watch the liquid level: Because pasta brands and noodle thickness vary, check the casserole when you remove the foil. If the noodles still look too dry, add a small splash of hot milk around the edges before returning the dish to the oven uncovered.
Let it rest before serving: Resting is especially important here because the sauce continues to thicken as it cools slightly. That short wait gives you creamier servings and helps the casserole hold together better on the plate.
